I bought a printer on sale last Christmas and now it doesn’t work and I want to kick it and spit on it and smash it against a brick wall. What happens next is a story that repeats itself in households across North America. I need to decide whether I’ll take it in to get fixed (god knows if the warranty is still good or applies to what’s wrong) or buy a new one at half the price of what it would cost to repair it. Sure, I would have a new printer, but I’d also be adding more junk to the growing number of dumped electronics on this planet. Happy with working black ink? Or ungrateful and green?
Annie Leonard’s “The Story of Electronics” couldn’t come out at a better time. After watching her short animated film, I realize there’s not a whole lot of good that can come from passing on my old printer. For starters, according to Leonard, my printer was originally “designed for the dump.” Even if I did decide to purchase a new printer and recycle the old one, the chances of it joining the e-waste export cycle are pretty high. That means that one person in a developing country will be responsible for taking the printer apart, harvesting it for reusable materials, and burning the rest. Not only will I be contributing to an unhealthy economic cycle, I’ll be putting that worker at risk by exposing them to my printer’s chemical contents. The more I think about this printer, the more depressed I get. Thankfully, Annie Leonard and the fine folks at Free Range Studios didn’t leave me hanging without a solution, or, at least the beginning of a solution.
According to Leonard, we’re all living in an unsustainable materials economy. To break this unsustainable cycle, we need to demand that companies who produce these materials and governments that regulate their production initiate “Product Take-Back” programs. Imagine a world where every time a company releases a product, they consider it’s life cycle and integrate a process that allows the consumer to return the product for safe re-use at the end of it’s time. Now imagine that this was the law. There would be no more temper tantrums when the printer you thought was such a steal breaks down (at least the dramatics would be kept at a minimum.) You could part with the printer with a good conscience. It’s a mighty big idea and we need to consider that big box electronic companies are not the only players in this game. We need to invite governments to the conversation as well. It’s time we supported this kind of “Take-Back” thinking.
For starters, I think I should send the Prime Minister my printer. Or what if we kicked off a campaign, asking Canadians to send their empty ink cartridges or old cell phone chargers to parliament, with a note attached? Wouldn’t that be something: 3.2 billion cell phone chargers earmarked for parliament. Now that’s not something they could ignore.
I agree that we need a serious rethink on our consumption of electronics. Out of the same frustration of the annual replacement of our printers, we’ve started leasing a printer. The arrangement is something like $20 a month for the printer and all the ink we can use. There is an incentive for this company to do their homework and find better quality printers to give to clients. And it isn’t perfect because they are not printer manufacturers and have to deal with the same built in obselence we all do (we’ve had them replace a printer once). But maybe it is a model that the manufacturers should look at. Do we really need to own printers? Or does what really matter is having the convience of being able to print something in our own homes? And if the manufacturers owned the printers it might be more in their interest to make them a higher quality that will last and make them easier to reuse or recycle since they’d be responsible for their disposal. Great psot Theo!
If this isn’t a case for a serious exploration of a service-and-flow economy, I don’t know what is. We need the service provided by a printer (ie. printing dissertations), but we don’t actually need to own a printer to do this, do we? Love that you’re leasing, Katie. Now, if we can just get, like, 3 billion people around the world to lease televisions, dvd players, computers, tablets, and ninjas we’ll get somewhere. Because no one actually needs to own a ninja…we just need their services from time to time.